Viewpoint: Caltrain and San Mateo County

by Mark Simon on July 17, 2020

It looks like San Francisco decided to take its railroad and go home.

Except, of course, that it’s not San Francisco’s railroad, which is why they want to destroy it.

The decision by San Francisco to kill the long-awaited regional funding source that would save Caltrain for all time is selfish, short-sighted, parochial, arrogant and plainly boneheaded. Ordinarily, it would be incomprehensible, except for this simple reality: San Francisco doesn’t care about Caltrain. San Francisco cares only about San Francisco.

If they can’t run it, they are happy to kill it.

The essence of this sordid matter can be found in a comment by San Francisco Supervisor Shamann Walton, who represents San Francisco, and only San Francisco, it appears, on the Caltrain regional board of directors.

According to Walton, “all important Caltrain decisions have to gel and be good for SamTrans, which is not always what is best for Caltrain.”

He actually has said it more succinctly in the past, but Walton basically is asserting that SamTrans runs Caltrain to the benefit of SamTrans. The irony is almost overwhelming.

Throughout the history of Caltrain, SamTrans has sacrificed for the betterment of Caltrain. Countless times and to a degree unmatched — unapproached — by the other two partners, San Francisco and Santa Clara County.

But let’s assume I don’t know anything about it. Does Walton?

It’s time for him to put up. Name an instance in which SamTrans acted in a way to undermine Caltrain. I don’t think he really knows, or cares. He wants to undermine Caltrain and its management by SamTrans. Why? Because he thinks the big players — San Francisco and Santa Clara County — should be running Caltrain.

What would make this laughable is that they can’t even run their own transit system. Meanwhile, Walton and his colleagues are using a phony reason to act in a profoundly selfish manner. It won’t be the last time.

I’ve written this before. San Mateo County has to begin throwing some regional weight around. Nowhere is that more abundantly clear than at Caltrain. If it was up to the leadership in the other two counties, Caltrain would make two stops in San Mateo County.

Editor’s note: The San Francisco Chronicle reports that San Francisco Supervisor Matt Haney is attempting to resurrect the sales tax after two of his colleagues teamed to scuttle it.

Mark Simon is a veteran journalist, including political writer and columnist for the Peninsula Times Tribune and 15 years as an executive at SamTrans and Caltrain. The was originally published in the San Mateo Daily Journal; used with permission.

InMenlo file photo showing Caltrain at Menlo Park train station (c) 2012



DG July 18, 2020 at 3:24 am

During Mayor Ed Lee’s tenure as Honorable Mayor of the city and County of San Francisco the supervisors, (in order to reduce green house gases, global warming and to reduce the influx of vehicles coming into the city of San Francisco), floated the concept to study the feasibility to implement a toll coming into the city and county of San Francisco, from the south, (vehicles entering from from Alameda and Marin Counties, have to pay respective Bay Bridge and Golden gate Bridge tolls), one of the San Mateo County governance officials immediately retorted that if San Francisco went thru with a toll entering San Francisco from San Mateo County, San Mateo County would create a toll upon entering into San Mateo County from San Francisco. I think that if the city needs to create a toll into the city from San Mateo we should consider that this would be a positive force for good to help reduce green house gases, global warming, fund revenue for transit, reduce private occupied vehicles, reduce traffic, regarding the multitude of transit agencies within our SF Bay area, (including CalTrains), that we should have one system of government, management). Back in our horse and buggy era, “way back, when San Francisco was first created as a city the original county of San Francisco extended to Santa Clara County when it would take a farmer one day to travel, (to bring farm goods into the city, (the farmer would have to stay inside the city overnight), one day to conduct business, and one day to travel back to the Old County). Apparently the people of the original old San Francisco did not like the way that they were treated by the people in the city, and they didn’t like the taxes that they had to pay to the city. The state governance that existed at that time decided to reign in the original border of the original old county of San Francisco (to what it is now).

Martin July 18, 2020 at 10:05 am

Caltrain is running empty trains due to the Covid-19 crisis, and is asking for a tax hike to keep them going. That’s ludicrous!! Now is the perfect time to shut down all Caltrain trains, and finish the electrification project. Without active trains passing by, construction crews can work 24 x 7, to complete all track related work. When Covid-19 has passed, offices are allowing workers inside, and commuters are commuting, bring Caltrain back as an electrified service.


Comments are closed.


Please help support InMenlo! Your contribution will help us continue to bring InMenlo to you. Click on the button below to contribute!